No, you don't automatically get a new key when you rekey a lock. Rekeying changes the internal pins inside your existing lock so your old keys stop working and new ones fit instead—but it's the same physical lock on your door. You'll need to ask your locksmith whether new keys are included in the job, because the answer varies depending on what you're paying for and what the lock needs.
If you've ever locked yourself out around Buriton or found yourself unsure whether to replace a lock completely or just rekey it, you've probably wondered what the actual difference is—and more importantly, which one makes sense for your situation. It's a fair question, and the answer matters because it affects your cost, your security, and whether you end up with working keys in your pocket.
Rekeying is a repair job, not a replacement. A locksmith removes the lock cylinder from your door, takes out the spring-loaded pins inside, and replaces them with a different set. Once those pins are swapped, your old key won't turn the lock anymore. Your new key will, because it's cut to match the new pin configuration. The lock itself stays right where it is—same hardware, same mounting, same door.
In practical terms: if you've had the same lock for years and you've lost a key, or someone moved out and you want to change who has access, rekeying is usually the faster and cheaper option. The locksmith doesn't have to remove anything from your wall or frame. They just work on the lock mechanism itself.
The tricky bit is figuring out how many new keys you need. Some locksmith jobs include one or two new keys as standard. Others charge separately for each key blank they cut. This guide on common locksmith mistakes covers what questions to ask upfront so you're not surprised when the invoice arrives.
If your lock is old, damaged, or the mechanism feels sticky, rekeying might not fix the underlying problem. A lock that's worn out will still be worn out after rekeying—you've just changed which key opens a faulty lock. That's not a good investment.
You should replace the entire lock if:
When you replace a lock, you get a completely new unit with new keys included. You're not restricted by the old lock's condition or its pin system. If security is your main concern, replacement gives you more control over what goes on your door.
The best way to figure out whether you need rekeying or replacement is to have a locksmith look at your lock and tell you honestly. Not every lock problem needs the expensive solution. Sometimes a £60 rekey solves your problem completely. Sometimes you need a new lock and anything less is money wasted.
What should you ask when you contact a locksmith in Buriton? Tell them what happened—you've lost a key, you want to change access after someone moved out, or your lock isn't working properly. They'll either suggest rekeying if the lock is solid, or recommend replacement if there's damage or wear.
A good locksmith will explain the difference and give you a quote for both options. You're then free to choose based on your budget and what makes sense for your home. Our article on what businesses know about locksmith services explains how to read a quote and spot red flags before you commit to anything.
The reason to care about this distinction is simple: if you pay for a rekey and don't get new keys included, or if you have a lock rekeyed when it really needed replacing, you've spent money on a half-solution. Neither scenario is ideal.
Before you ring a locksmith, make a note of what triggered the need. Did you lose your keys? Is the lock broken? Do you need multiple new keys or just one? When a locksmith comes out, they'll ask these questions anyway, but having your answer ready helps them give you a faster and more accurate quote.
If you're in a rush—stuck outside your house on Chapel Lane or locked out unexpectedly—you can still ask for details on the phone. Most locksmiths can tell you whether rekeying or replacement is the right call before they even see the lock. Read more here about response times if speed is important to you.
The key takeaway: rekeying changes which key fits your lock, but you don't necessarily get new keys automatically. Ask your locksmith upfront what's included in the quote, how many keys you'll receive, and whether rekeying is actually the right solution for your lock's condition. That conversation saves money and headaches.
If you're in Buriton and you need honest advice on whether to rekey or replace, get in touch with Locksmith Buriton. We'll look at your lock, tell you what it actually needs, and give you a transparent quote with no surprises. Call us or message us today—we're here to help.
We have secure, flexible units available in the area. Get in touch with Locksmith Buriton today.
Find Out More →